Your business withdrew cryptocurrency from a platform weeks before it filed for bankruptcy. Months later, a litigation trust sends a demand seeking repayment. The letter lists your withdrawals, assigns them a dollar value, and offers a discount if you settle quickly.
You did not manage the platform or know its financial condition. You simply withdrew assets you believed belonged to you. Why should you return them?
Bankruptcy law can permit recovery of certain transfers even when the recipient did nothing dishonest. But a demand is not a judgment. Before paying, admitting liability, or accepting the sender’s calculations, examine the asserted claim, transaction records, available defenses, and deadlines.
First, verify the demand and identify the proceeding
Confirm the bankruptcy case, debtor entity, sender’s authority, and whether a lawsuit has been filed. The party pursuing recovery might be a debtor in possession, trustee, or representative appointed under a confirmed plan.
Verify payment instructions independently through established case channels. A message containing accurate account information still deserves scrutiny before you send money or connect a wallet.
Separate a settlement deadline from a court deadline. Under Bankruptcy Rule 7012, the general deadline to answer an adversary complaint is 30 days after issuance of the summons, unless the court sets another time. Different provisions apply to service abroad. Negotiations do not automatically extend the deadline.
Counsel should also examine timeliness under 11 U.S.C. § 546(a), including relevant trustee appointments, case closure or dismissal, and any tolling issues. A request to sign a tolling agreement warrants separate review because it can preserve claims that otherwise might expire.
Determine what kind of clawback is alleged
“Clawback” describes several recovery theories with different requirements.
A preference claim under 11 U.S.C. § 547(b) generally concerns a transfer of the debtor’s property to or for a creditor, for an existing debt, while insolvent, within 90 days before bankruptcy. The period can extend to one year for insiders. The transfer must also improve the creditor’s recovery compared with the statutory hypothetical Chapter 7 liquidation. Recipient misconduct is not an element.
A fraudulent-transfer claim under 11 U.S.C. § 548 instead may involve the debtor’s actual fraudulent intent or a transfer for less than reasonably equivalent value combined with specified financial conditions. Its general lookback is two years. The label does not necessarily accuse the recipient of fraud.
Through Section 544(b), an estate representative may also invoke applicable nonbankruptcy avoidance law, potentially reaching older transfers. Do not assume that a withdrawal outside 90 days is automatically safe.
Reconstruct the transactions before debating the amount
Build a transaction history covering the challenged period and enough earlier activity to establish how the account normally operated. Preserve:
- Complete account exports, statements, and withdrawal confirmations.
- Wallet addresses, networks, transaction hashes, and timestamps.
- Deposits, repayments, rewards, fees, and internal account transfers.
- Account terms and records of changes between custody and lending products.
- Communications about withdrawals, special assistance, or account restrictions.
Match each demanded transfer to your records. Check for duplicates, unsuccessful withdrawals, incorrect recipients, and transfers attributed to the wrong entity. An omnibus exchange wallet does not by itself identify the customer or legal relationship behind a payment.
Suppose a business withdrew $200,000, later deposited $80,000, and subsequently withdrew another $30,000. Neither adding all withdrawals nor subtracting all deposits necessarily produces the legally recoverable amount. Sequence, purpose, and the applicable defenses matter.
Avoid sending an improvised explanation before reconciling the records. Statements about ownership, timing, or why you withdrew may become evidence.
Examine whether the transferred assets belonged to the debtor
“I withdrew my own crypto” is understandable, but the legal answer depends on the account relationship.
In In re Celsius Network LLC, 647 B.R. 631 (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. 2023), the court relied on the applicable Terms of Use to conclude that Earn assets became Celsius’s property, subject to reserved defenses. That ruling did not establish that every asset held by every crypto platform belongs to the platform.
A custody arrangement preserving customer ownership may present different issues from a product transferring title in exchange for a repayment obligation. Examine the operative agreement, how assets were handled, and any relevant orders already entered in the bankruptcy.
Kelman’s discussion of stablecoin yield, rewards, and lending arrangements explains why the product’s label alone does not tell customers what rights they retain. Those distinctions can become critical when a withdrawal is challenged.
Evaluate defenses against the actual claim
For preferences, Section 547(c) supplies several potential defenses. Ordinary course generally requires an ordinarily incurred debt and either ordinary dealings between the parties or ordinary business terms. Contemporaneous exchange requires an intended and substantially contemporaneous exchange for new value. Subsequent new value concerns qualifying value supplied after the challenged transfer, subject to statutory conditions.
These are evidence questions. A documented pattern of routine withdrawals may support a different analysis from an unusually large withdrawal obtained through special access. Later deposits require examination of how they were treated and whether subsequent repayments affect the defense.
Good faith also operates differently across claims. Section 548(c) protects a qualifying good-faith transferee to the extent of value given. Under Section 550(b), certain subsequent transferees receive protections unavailable on the same basis to initial transferees. Receiving funds through an intermediary therefore requires careful tracing.
Technical financial-contract safe harbors may warrant review, but using cryptocurrency does not automatically qualify a transaction.
Challenge unsupported valuation assumptions
Ask whether the claimant seeks particular tokens, their value, or a negotiated dollar payment. Section 550(a) permits recovery of transferred property or, if the court orders, its value; the appropriate valuation analysis requires attention to the claim and governing decisions.
Check token quantities, pricing sources, valuation dates, and treatment of fees. A customer’s bankruptcy claim valuation and the amount sought in a clawback are distinct issues. Do not assume that either petition-date prices or current market prices necessarily control both.
For volatile assets, the choice of valuation date can materially change settlement economics. Require an explanation of the methodology.
Evaluate settlement as a complete agreement
A discounted demand can still be excessive if the claim is weak or the calculation is wrong. Conversely, settlement may make commercial sense when litigation expense, uncertainty, and management time outweigh the expected benefit of defending.
Review the release as closely as the payment amount. It should identify covered transfers, released parties, remaining claims, payment obligations, and whether court approval or dismissal is required. Confirm what happens if payment is late.
Also address your claim against the estate. Under Section 502(d) and (h), avoidance liability can affect claim allowance, while recovery may give rise to a claim treated as prepetition. A settlement should clarify whether relevant claim rights are preserved, waived, or otherwise resolved. Repayment does not guarantee a matching distribution.
Kelman PLLC’s bankruptcy and insolvency practice addresses digital asset insolvency matters. If you receive a clawback demand, contact Kelman PLLC to discuss the asserted transfers, response deadlines, and options before committing to repayment.
Attorney Advertising. This article provides general information about U.S. bankruptcy law, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Defenses and outcomes depend on the transactions, governing law, and case-specific orders.
